Silver’s Archetype dive watch is a superb watch, however falls brief if in case you have greater homage expectations for it. Do you have to buy one?
The last time I wrote about Silver, I was dissatisfied that they have been dangerous at communication and backed out once they had agreed to let us evaluate the watch. Since that time, they shipped the watch to their backers. We are capable of deliver this assessment to you thru considered one of their clients.
Because the watch is meant to be a Rolex 5513/5517 (or Tudor 7016 relying on which dial and shade mixture you selected), I’m going to assessment it two methods: first, as a watch normally, and separately, as a 5513/5517/Tudor 7016 homage.
The Silver Archetype 1 is a superb watch. It prices $399 (discounted from $449 USD), and comes outfitted with a Miyota 9015. The 9015 is reasonably priced, reliable, and rated by Miyota to be correct inside -10 to +30 seconds a day. Considering that different watches in the homage subject with a 9015 sell for $650, this can be a implausible look ahead to the worth.
The instance I’ve here arrived operating at -Zero.three seconds a day, which is admittedly very correct. (I checked this using the Accuracy2 measurement device from ONEOF.
The watch is 39.5mm in diameter, and 47mm lug to lug. These dimensions result in a cushty, classic-sized watch. I wore it for two weeks, and I’m pretty sensitive to how heavy a watch is, and the way snug it’s. Simply, Silver could be very snug.
When it comes to peak, the watch is 12.5mm from back to the prime of the calmly domed crystal. The crystal is AR coated on the inside it, which makes viewing the dial super-clear.
On the wrist, contributing to the consolation of the put on is the bracelet. The bracelet tapers from 20mm at the lugs to 16mm at fold-over clasp. The links are brushed on the prime surface and polished on the sides.
The top-links on the bracelet are strong, and feminine, just like these used by trendy Tudor, or ORIS. The top hyperlinks aren’t machined, and like all molded ones, look a bit smooth. That’s not mistaken for a vintage watch homage.
The lume is colored to appear to be aged classic radium, and glows a shiny inexperienced. It lasts for hours in the dark after sporting for a while outdoor.
All of this stuff make the Silver Archetype One an excellent watch. It’s a strong worth, a superb performing movement, comprised of 316L chrome steel, stainless bracelet, and AR coated sapphire crystal.
It comes in a pleasant, small-ish travel case with a deal with. It holds two watches, has a zippered mesh pocket in the lid, and has a pleasant handle on the back hinge. Truthfully, I’d wish to have a couple of of those instances around for other watches, too.
First, I need to lay out how Silver set my expectations:
The blue, snowflake version of the famous army dive watches was extra extensively issued because it didn’t have be to customized created from the unique producer. This is our painstakingly detailed and exacting homage – in contrast to anything out there.As such, all elements are customized made (excepting the motion). – The Blue Snowflake product page
The emphasis on “painstakingly detailed and exacting homage” set me as much as anticipate it might be very near the unique watch it’s paying tribute to. If that had been the solely mention, I might have moved on. But they continued to set my expectations high.
My dad’s dad (Grandpa Silver) had a Rolex 5513 Army. He cherished it a lot it turned a “safe queen” which was ultimately bought after his passing. My dad tried to track it down however gave up as costs soared for these uncommon items. I inherited my dad’s love of the 5513 however might never discover an homage to my liking. My father and I tried virtually all the reasonably priced homages out there throughout the years however there was all the time one thing not fairly proper (too huge, too long, flawed arms, flawed font, phantom date wheel, and so on.).
“As close to the real thing as possible…”
These words turned our mission…so, we made our ARCHETYPE ONE collection to be an exacting tribute to the nice and elusive Rolex 5513/5517 Army and the lesser recognized Tudor milsub however with the highest grade trendy materials.
We sweated over the shape and curves of the case. We rendered and rendered until we might see the resemblances we have been pining for. Then we poured over every millimeter of the engineering schematics till we finally had prototypes we needed – a 5513/5517 army tribute watch like none else out there.
So, Silver’s words: they needed to make a painstaking, exacting, homage as close to the real factor as potential, sweating over each millimeter.
Did they reside up to it?
First, there are few simply accessible pristine examples of the Rolex 5513. The watch was comprised of 1962 until 1989. By this time, many examples have had put on, servicing, and sprucing of case edges. The 5517 was made for one yr, 1977, and is essentially a 5513 with sword arms and a 60 minute bezel insert, manufactured for the British Military.
With that stated, there are sufficient good examples of the 5513 that it isn’t exhausting to match Silver Archetype One with a 5513 and see if each shape matches up or not. We in contrast it with two examples of the Rolex 5513 Submariner.
The crown guards are virtually a very good match. This can be a element many attempts get flawed, and here, they have just a bit an excessive amount of slope to their prime floor and really feel somewhat brief. They’re still higher than many different watches.
The profile of the case is a miss. The aspect shape of the case doesn’t match the 5513 very properly at all. 5513 is thinner in the middle, where Archetype One is straight across.
- 5513 aspect view
- 5513 aspect view
- Silver Archetype One aspect view
The caseback edge on a 5513 extends almost all the option to the edge of the case. Comparatively, the caseback of Archetype One stops brief about twice the distance that the Rolex does.
- (not the similar 5513 as photographed above)
The bezel shape is okay. The case edge has no bevels where the sides meet the prime of the case.
The bracelet is a strong link, the place the unique had either hole middle hyperlinks or folded hyperlinks, depending on which yr 5513 we’re speaking about. By the 1980s, they came on the 93150 bracelet which shipped on 14060 and 14060M into the 2000s. Sure, that is being somewhat specific – however they did say they needed as close to the real factor as attainable.
Which is fascinating, because the unique 5513 Submariner used an acrylic bezel and a friction based mostly bi-directional dive bezel. Sapphire is a wise improve, and one Rolex made with the 14060 Submariner. Sapphire provides larger depth scores and better water resistance, growing the Sub from 200M to 300M depths.
Some individuals assume a dive bezel have to be unidirectional with a click spring. These individuals are improper. The Sub-with-a-date acquired the click on spring unidirectional bezel in 1978 with the 1680 Submariner. The no-date Sub remained friction spring and bi-directional till 1989. That didn’t make it any less of a dive watch.
In reality, Tudor shipped a no-date Sub, the 79090, from 1989 to 1995. It had a friction spring bi-directional dive bezel. The point is, Rolex and Tudor both shipped bi-directional dive bezels properly into the late 80s and mid-1990s, and Silver chose to move to a click on spring uni-directional bezel.
That is high-quality, however it isn’t “as close to the real thing as possible” when UNDONE’s BASECAMP ships with the bi-directional friction one. It’s a concession, perhaps to clients who gained’t know the history, but concessions aren’t no-compromises-as-close-to-the-original, either. I perceive these decisions, but I feel it’s necessary we all know where Silver diverged intentionally from the unique they’re paying tribute to.
The dial fonts are a combined bag: the SILVER font is superb, and nails the form of the S and R as you may find in “SUBMARINER” in another watch. The depth font is completely italicized, where on the watch it pays tribute to, solely M and FT are italicized.
Lastly, there’s one other place to look for accuracy. Dial measurement and dial opening. The dial measurement of a 5513 is 26.3mm. The dial measurement of a Silver is 28.5mm, which makes the opening bigger, too.
So why do I hold mentioning Tudor 7016? The watch we borrowed to deliver you this assessment is the blue snowflake variant of Archetype. Rolex 5513 was produced from 1962 until 1989. The comparable Tudor model from the similar time interval, utilizing comparable case development and details, was the 1964 Tudor 7928. However that mannequin has a really 5512 Gilt Submariner-like dial. To get the mannequin that matches up with snowflake arms and hour markers, we’ve got to look to Tudor 7016.
Tudor 7016 was produced from 1969 to 1975. It was the first snowflake arms and dial combination, was obtainable in black dial, with no date perform. If we need to be specific, the blue dial variant came in the subsequent Tudor Submariner, 9401/Zero. It was out there in 1975 with blue or black dial, and without the date (9411/0 had the date perform.)
None of this makes Silver Archetype One a nasty watch. It’s a superb watch. It’s as much as you whether or not it reaches the degree of being an correct 5513 homage. It absolutely pays tribute to the Tudor 7016 in this type (blue snowflake dial, blue bezel insert, snowflake palms), and I take pleasure in the lighter blue dial towards the dark blue bezel. It’s very snug to wear.
The Silver Archetype One is Silver’s first watch. They have further models deliberate. It’s clear that this was not a listing train, the place they might have used instances and elements picked out of choices already made. For that purpose, I’m somewhat saddened that they didn’t get nearer to their self-declared objective. Had they only made an excellent watch and not stated exacting detail was the aim, I wouldn’t have been let down. As it’s, it’s a superb watch with an ideal motion, and arrived holding fantastic time. It’s just reasonably priced fun. The Silver Archetype One is out there from SilverWatchCo.com for $399 USD.
- Brand & Mannequin: Silver Archetype One
- Worth: pricing starts at $399
- Who we expect it may be for: You need a vintage styled dive watch with a well-performing motion.
- Would I buy one for myself based mostly on what I’ve seen?: I like it. I like it lots.
- If I might make one design suggestion, it will be: Goal at a more exacting homage, or think about not setting our expectations to consider that’s what we’re getting.
- What spoke to me the most about this watch: It’s all there. The straightforward to turn bezel with not a variety of backplay, the wonderful lume, and tasteful shade decisions relating to the blue bezel and blue dial.
Tech Specs from Silver
- Case measurement: 39.5mm, 47mm lug to lug
- Peak: 12.5mm
- Case material: 316L Stainless Seel
- Crystal: sapphire
- Strap: chrome steel bracelet
- Movement: Miyota 9015